Paul Scholes has maintained his critical stance on Lisandro Martinez, refusing to apologize for comments made before the Manchester derby in the 22nd round of the Premier League last week. Scholes and fellow former Man Utd player Nicky Butt had likened Martinez to a child, suggesting Erling Haaland could "pick him up and throw him into the net."

However, Martinez delivered a solid performance in that match, significantly contributing to containing Haaland and helping Man Utd secure a 2-0 victory in interim manager Michael Carrick’s debut. Following the game, the Argentine defender publicly challenged Scholes and Butt to "come over and talk directly."

Paul Scholes speaks on The Overlap Fan Debate program. *Photo: Daily Mail*

Speaking on The Overlap Fan Debate program on 23/1, Scholes conceded that his phrasing was "perhaps not good" but firmly maintained his opinion. "Looking back, what we said was perhaps not good, but I won't apologize," he stated. "Physically, there's clearly a disparity. The way it was said wasn't right, but the meaning remains."

The former England midfielder then argued that Martinez has only had one strong performance, reiterating the defender's unconvincing displays in previous rounds. "I hope he proves me wrong, but look at the match against Brighton with Danny Welbeck or Burnley before that," he added.

Scholes also countered suggestions that he and Butt contributed to a toxic atmosphere around Man Utd, affirming his desire for his former club to win every week. "When Jamie Carragher or I were playing, we were also criticized," the 51-year-old former player emphasized. "Playing for a big club like Man Utd, you have to learn to deal with that."

Similarly, Butt maintained a firm stance, deeming Martinez’s reaction overly sensitive. "If you're that sensitive, you shouldn't play for a big club," the former England midfielder stated. "Criticism will follow you throughout your career."

Scholes concluded that his opinion on Martinez remains unchanged, as one outstanding performance is not enough. "He needs to show that form over a long period if he wants to prove Man Utd can win titles with him," he remarked. "The upcoming match against Arsenal will give us more answers."

Martinez (red shirt) contests the ball with Erling Haaland during Man Utd's 2-0 victory over Man City in the 22nd round of the Premier League at Old Trafford, Manchester, England on 17/1/2026. *Photo: AP*

In response, another former Man Utd player, Rio Ferdinand, spoke out in defense of Martinez, indirectly criticizing Paul Scholes and Nicky Butt for their personal comments. Speaking on the Rio Ferdinand Presents program, the former Man Utd defender suggested the situation was "being pushed too far."

"This isn't a personal conflict as many think, but this week there have been statements that crossed the line, becoming quite personal," Ferdinand stated. "I've spoken with Martinez many times, both online and in person. He just wants to play well, win, and bring Man Utd back to its established standards."

According to Ferdinand, the Argentine defender is a progressive and eager-to-learn player. He recounted visiting the training ground, having coffee, and feeling that Martinez was "like a sponge," always wanting to absorb information. "His playing style also reflects his true self: straightforward, honest, and the type of player any dressing room needs," Ferdinand shared.

The former Man Utd captain also suggested that Martinez's reaction was understandable, as anyone in that situation has the right to speak up when feeling uncomfortable. "Martinez didn't say 'come here to fight'," the former England defender added, "but simply wanted a direct, frank conversation if there's an issue. We're talking about a World Cup winner, someone who understands very well how to win."

Ferdinand simultaneously emphasized the boundaries of punditry, asserting that he always avoids personal attacks. The former England international recalled publicly apologizing to Phil Jones in 2024, believing he had overstepped the mark when commenting on the defender's career and injuries. "I'm always proud that I only analyze expertise, form, and performance, not targeting individuals," Ferdinand affirmed. "If I feel I've gone too far, I'm ready to admit and apologize. My view is: if you can say something straight to someone's face, then say it. If not, perhaps you should reconsider."

Hong Duy (according to Daily Mail)