Released on 11/9, the martial arts drama starring Cheng Yi has sparked controversy over its content and quality, according to The Paper. Many viewers noticed errors like Cheng Yi's character, Xiao Thu Thuy, holding a script with dialogue and wearing modern plastic sandals.
Viewers also shared clips showcasing illogical plot points, unconvincing special effects, and unrealistic fight scenes, suggesting a lack of attention to quality from the production team. The Paper described these as errors that shouldn't appear in a television production. "This demonstrates a lack of professionalism and seriousness towards their work", commented writer Ma Thuong.
![]() |
Xiao Thu Thuy riding a horse off a cliff. Photo: Sohu |
Besides these oversights, the main character's appearance also drew criticism. Some viewers felt Xiao Thu Thuy's elaborate costume, polished makeup, and pink nail polish clashed with the image of a hero in a dangerous martial arts world. Others argued that the production team has the right to portray martial arts in a modern style.
Based on Wen Rui An's novel "Shenzhou Qixia", "Pho son hai" revolves around Xiao Minh Minh, a young man fascinated by martial arts novels who imagines himself as the wandering hero Xiao Thu Thuy. Initially inexperienced and unskilled, Xiao Thu Thuy receives guidance from masters and eventually becomes a great hero. The drama, directed by Ren Hai Tao and Lam Phong, also stars prominent young Chinese actors like Gulnazar, Tong Meng Shi, and Chen Yu Qi. Hong Kong actors Gallen Lo and Julian Cheung appear in supporting roles.
The Cover reports that China's National Radio and Television Administration recently introduced reforms to encourage high-quality television and internet content creation, as audiences increasingly favor short videos and summarized content. This shift presents an unavoidable challenge for those in film and television. The necessary response is to create more exceptional and refined works that demonstrate the unique value and entertainment of long-form content, something "fast food" entertainment cannot replace.
Nhu Anh (according to The Paper)